Thursday, June 28, 2007

Will a raw vegetarian diet make you dumber?

Well, no, but according to a recent news article in Science, the addition of meat and cooked foods to the Homo erectus diet may have led to the dramatic expansion of our ancestors' brains and cognitive abilities.

Between 1.9 million and 200,000 years ago, the brains of our ancestors tripled in size (from 500 cc in Australopithecus to about 1500 cc in Neanderthals), a feat that required a massive increase in energy supply. Brains are rather greedy structures, utilizing 60% of a newborn baby's energy expenditure, and 25% of a resting adult's. In contrast, the average ape brain uses only 8% of the animal's total energy expenditure, despite similar basal metabolic rates. So what led to this glorious caloric upsurge?

One well-supported theory proposes that calorie-dense meat provided the necessary fuel. The high caloric return (not necessarily the high protein content) of meat made it a far more efficient fuel, capable of supporting a 35-55% increase in caloric needs. Moreover, a diet with a greater proportion of meat permits a smaller gut, allowing the allocation of energy saved from digestion and tissue maintenance to feeding the voracious brain. One line of evidence that supports this hypothesis stems from correlational primate studies: capuchin monkeys, which eat an omnivorous diet and have small guts, are considered the most intelligent New World monkeys.; in contrast, Howler monkeys, while bereft of significant brainpower, have large guts to accompany their vegetarian diets.

According to Harvard primatologist Richard Wrangham, "a diet of wildebeest tartare and antelope sashimi alone isn't enough." By breaking down collagen and starches, cooking is a form of pre-digestion, thus lightening the load for the GI tract and allowing greater energy expenditure elsewhere. In one study, pythons fed cooked, ground meat spent 23.4% less energy digesting relative to those which ate raw meat; in another, mice raised on cooked meat gained 29% more weight than mice fed raw meat.

Theoretically, cooking and meat could have provided a great enough surge in calories to fuel the major expansion of our ancestors' brains and cognitive abilities, but the idea is still controversial. Back then, cooking required fire, and evidence for the earliest controlled fires is a bit ambiguous. The earliest such evidence is from about 800,000 years ago, and the earliest evidence for cooking (e.g. hearths) is from no earlier than 250,000 years ago, with questionable evidence dating to 300,000 to 500,000 years ago.

Nevertheless, it's an intriguing explanation for this feature of our evolutionary history. Of course, as we are no longer subjected to the same evolutionary pressures, it's not exactly a recipe for intelligence in modern society. It's possible, according to Wrangham, that "Western food is now so highly processed and easy to digest that...food labels may underestimate net calorie counts and may be another cause of obesity." That said, I love a good barbecue, and in the land of "raw foodies" and "fake stake [sic]," it's refreshing to see meat and cooking receive some due recognition for their delicious role in our natural history.

*For those without a Science subscription, Jake at Pure Pedantry has some key excerpts from the article

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

1Y0-A08
1Y0-A11
1z0-042
1z0-051
1Z0-053
220-601
220-602
220-701
220-702
310-065
310-200
310-202
312-50
350-001
350-001-Lab
350-018
350-029
350-030
350-030-LAB
350-040
640-553
640-721
640-802
640-816
640-822
640-863
642-062
642-067
642-072
642-105
642-145
642-164
642-357
642-359
642-373
642-383

Anonymous said...

vuitton replica series is designed by three famous designers who represent the fashion trend. As well known, louis replica stores are all over the world. Wherever you are, you could get the genuine and fashionable louis vuitton replica with the reasonable price.

Unknown said...

The Breitling Bentley was first developed in 1969 - Chrono Superocean created the Caliber II, the World's for self-winding chronograph movement. Superocean was easily distinguishable by the placement of the crown on the left-hand-side of the casing. These Chronomat B01 still place the crown of the left-side.

A Coach Wallets can be quite a useful item for a young woman to carry. Most of Coach Ergo are of quite a large size. That makes them convenient for the amount of items they can help a person carry. In addition, they are quite well known for Coach Legacy sleek and attractive appearance. In fact, a Coach Luggage is a coveted and sought after item for many young women.

The copyright THE DREW CAREY SHOW laws are in place to ensure that the owner of the copyright is protected from any types of fraud and illegal activities, which includes THE DREW CAREY SHOW DVD duplication of any form. It is best to simply avoid making any duplicates of any THE DREW CAREY SHOW DVD COLLECTION movies to protect yourself and your friends. Purchasing the movie will help in support of your favorite actors and directors.