Monday, July 9, 2007

Williams Syndrome and human sociality

There's a great article by David Dobbs in the New York Times Magazine about Williams Syndrome (WMS), a condition with a diverse and remarkable array of cognitive symptoms. I have vivid memories of my first exposure to WMS--watching a documentary hosted by Oliver Sacks for my "Psychology of Music" class. In one of the first scenes, Dr. Sacks introduces himself to a 6-year old girl with WMS, who eagerly and cheerfully insists "Don't be shy, Mr. Sacks." In another scene he takes her to a sandwich shop, where she enthusiastically engages the employees and fellow customers in conversation, offering hugs to all within reach. This behavior exemplifies one of the most remarkable endowments of children with WMS--endearing, socially fearless personalities, marked by extreme gregariousness and emotional empathy.

This charm is facilitated by a peculiarly rich vocabulary and proficiency with language; for example, when asked to name some animals, a WMS child responded "Brontosaurus, tyranadon, brontasaurus rex, dinosaurs, elephant, dog, cat, lion, baby hippopotamus, ibex, whale, bull, yak, zebra, puppy, kitten, tiger, koala, dragon..." quickly and fluidly naming exotic (though occasionally non-existent) animals as if reading them off a list. When striking conversations with strangers, they are extremely loquacious, to the point where they appear to burden the listener with verbosity.

Adding to the list of aptitudes of WMS people is a great affinity for music (hence learning about the condition in my "Psychology of Music" class). People with WMS can have savantlike musical skills, and those without notable musical gifts nevertheless feel "drawn" to music, an inclination likely aided by an acute sensitivity to sound. One scene of the documentary featured WMS children walking through the woods, commenting on how loud the bees and rustling leaves were (sounds which were more or less unnoticed by Sacks).

These remarkable virtuosities with language, social interaction, and music are accompanied, however, by profound cognitive impairments. The average IQ of a person with WMS is in the 60's, and the vast majority cannot live independently. Despite their seeming fluency with verbal communication, people with WMS have poor language comprenension, incapable of understanding the underlying meaning of most conversations. Their communication, though voluminous, lacks depth and subtlety, and rarely goes beyond "small talk."

This intriguing disconnect pervades social interactions beyond spoken language; in spite of their gregariousness, people with WMS often fail to grasp social cues, including facial expression and body language. Moreover, the extreme geniality of WMS people is indicative of an underlying problem: a complete lack of social fear. According to the article, "functional brain scans have shown that the brain’s main fear processor, the amygdala, which in most of us shows heightened activity when we see angry or worried faces, shows no reaction when a person with Williams views such faces. It’s as if they see all faces as friendly."

Children with WMS also have significant deficiencies in spatial processing and dealing with numbers. In another memorable scene from the documentary, Sacks presents the child with a plate of muffins, asking her how many she thought were on the plate. "3," she immediately and eagerly replied. There were clearly over 10. When then asked to make a + shape out of four rectangular pieces, she arranged them haphazardly, seemingly at random, at which point she cheerfully announced "Done!"

WMS thus provides a captivating mélange of cognitive strengths and weaknesses. Unlike most forms of mental retardation, in which most or all cognitive abilities are concurrently impaired, the distinct peaks and valleys of aptitudes in WMS allows a dissociation between specific abilities and "general intelligence." Further, the genetic basis of WMS is known: it arises from a deletion of ~28 known genes from chromosome 7. Thus, WMS offers a tantalizing opportunity to understand the genetic influences on complex brain functions, which I plan to explore in a future post.

This post, however, was inspired by a separate, equally captivating story woven by the WMS condition: the implications for human social behavior. Why, despite their affability and charm, do WMS people find it hopelessly difficult to make friends? According to Dobbs, this paradox "makes clear that while we are innately driven to connect with others, this affiliative drive alone will not win this connection. To bond with others we must show not just charm but sophisticated cognitive skills."

So why is it that all our relationships, even casual friendships, demand intelligence? Why was it so difficult to believe that Jenny would marry Forrest Gump? The article broaches two related and overlapping evolutionary theories, the "social brain" theory and the "Machiavellian-intelligence" theory. These theories propose, respectively, that humans evolved large brains to generate complex social relationships, and that deception and manipulation (and the ability to identify these two behaviors) are necessary to successfully compete amongst other members of society. Thus, as Steven Pinker suggests in The Language Instinct, "human evolution was propelled more by a cognitive arms race among social competitors than by mastery of technology and the physical environment."

Social life presents a convoluted tension, involving (as stated by Ralph Adolphs and quoted by Dobbs), a “complex and dynamic interplay between two opposing factors: on the one hand, groups can provide better security from predators, better mate choice and more reliable food; on the other hand, mates and food are available also to competitors from within the group.” Thus, our survival is contingent on a delicate balance between getting along with others and outperforming them. Requisite for maintaining this balance is a comprehensive understanding of subtle and complicated social dynamics, enabling both manipulation and the detection of manipulation by others. Dobbs writes that:

"People with Williams, however, don’t do this so well. Generating and detecting deception and veiled meaning requires not just the recognition that people can be bad but a certain level of cognitive power that people with Williams typically lack. In particular it requires what psychologists call “theory of mind,” which is a clear concept of what another person is thinking and the recognition that the other person a) may see the world differently than you do and b) may actually be thinking something different from what he’s saying.

...it’s clear that Williamses do not generally sniff out the sorts of hidden meanings and intentions that lie behind so much human behavior."
The article concludes with a fascinating question about being human: is our social behavior driven more by the urge to connect or the urge to manipulate the connection? Are we trying to make friends, or do we only care about being genetically more successful than our peers?
"We dominate the planet because we can think abstractly, accumulate and relay knowledge and manipulate the environment and one another. By this light our social behavior rises more from big brains than from big hearts.

...

The disassociation of so many elements in Williams — the cognitive from the connective, social fear from nonsocial fear, the tension between the drive to affiliate and the drive to manipulate — highlights how vital these elements are and, in most of us, how delicately, critically entwined. Yet these splits in Williams also clarify which, of caring and comprehension, offers the more vital contribution. For if Williams confers disadvantage by granting more care than comprehension, reversing this imbalance creates a far more problematic phenotype.

As Robert Sapolsky of the Stanford School of Medicine puts it: “Williams have great interest but little competence. But what about a person who has competence but no warmth, desire or empathy? That’s a sociopath. Sociopaths have great theory of mind. But they couldn’t care less.”"

Link to the NYTM article.

21 comments:

AlvaroF said...

this was such a beautiful article, showing how to tell a great story while discussing in depth cognition and evolution. congrats to the NYT!

Anonymous said...

You may have not intended to do so, but I think you have managed to express the state of mind that a lot of people are in. The sense of wanting to help, but not knowing how or where, is something a lot of us are going through. Please come visit my site San Antonio Directory when you

Anonymous said...

You may have not intended to do so, but I think you have managed to express the state of mind that a lot of people are in. The sense of wanting to help, but not knowing how or where, is something a lot of us are going through. Please come visit my site San Antonio Texas TX when you

Anonymous said...

I really liked your blog! You have some great content. Check out my blog and give me some feedback Please come visit my site Lubbock Business Search when you got time.

Anonymous said...

I really liked your blog! You have some great content. Check out my blog and give me some feedback Please come visit my site Business Phone Directory of Lubbock Texas TX when you got time.

Anonymous said...

Find and download that you need at Rapidshare Search Engine.
Top Site List Free Proxy Site Free Download mp3 Michael Jackson song All Michael Jackson Lyrics Hollywood Celebrity Gossip Download Mp3 Gratis

Anonymous said...

Thanks for posting, definitely going to subscribe! See you on my reader. Please come visit my site Directory Arlington City when you got time.

Anonymous said...

Fitness Logo | Entertainment Logos | Computer Logos

rr8004 said...

Glad I stumbled into this article! Finally, got what I was looking for to put on my school report... Thanks for sharing this. Please come visit my site Portland Business Services And Classifieds when you got time.

rr8004 said...

Glad I stumbled into this article! Finally, got what I was looking for to put on my school report... Thanks for sharing this. Please come visit my site Oregon OR Phone Directory when you got time.

rr8004 said...

You got a really useful blog I have been here reading for about an hour. I am a newbee and your success is very much an inspiration for me. Please come visit my site Business Yellow Pages Detroit when you got time.

rr8004 said...

You got a really useful blog I have been here reading for about an hour. I am a newbee and your success is very much an inspiration for me. Please come visit my site Detroit Directory Businesses when you got time.

rr8004 said...

this seems like it would be a very interesting blog to keep up with. Please come visit my site Find Business Tucson when you got time.

rr8004 said...

this seems like it would be a very interesting blog to keep up with. Please come visit my site Tucson Yellow Pages when you got time.

Anonymous said...

642-524
642-533
642-566
642-591
642-611
642-631
642-642
642-654
642-655
642-661
642-681
642-691
642-736
642-746
642-812
642-825
642-845
642-873
642-892
642-901
642-971
642-973
642-974
642-975
646-046
646-204
646-230
646-363
646-563
646-656
646-671
646-985
650-175
650-180
650-251
650-393

Unknown said...

After wave seen Kate Moss holding her navy-like Gucci Sloane bag, this time, we see her toting that Louis vuitton bags Suede Asphalt Purse which is part of collaboration between louis vuitton handbags and director and style icon lv . Last time, she looks so relaxed with her simple getup and now she looks really chic with her contoured louis vuitton , blazers and frayed shorts.

Unknown said...

The smart and correct response would be to search elsewhere for that particular Coach bags and many others until you get it and never give up on your dreams. If your dream is to own Coach Hamptons , then make your dreams come true by going online and finding that handbag that you want. You are sure to get a Coach Legacy for u or that Coach Ergo you've dreamt of.


As a member of the Breitling Watches series, the Navitimer World watch composes of a self winding mechanical, uni-directional bezel, cambered sapphire crystal with a stainless steel case, and Montbrillant Datora comes with a strong water resistant capability on Chrono Superocean , reaching 300 meters.

Anonymous said...

nice
jual obat ambeien yang sudah parah
jual obat ambeien sudah parah
obat ambeien yang sudah parah
jual obat ambeien parah
jual obat ambeien yang parah
obat ambeien sudah parah untuk pria dan wanita
obat ambeien parah untuk pria dan wanita
obat ambeien sudah parah untuk pria
pengobatan ambeien sudah parah untuk pria dan wanita
obat ambeien sudah parah untuk wanita

Anonymous said...

thank you
home design
home theatre set up
home theatre seating ideas
my gallery
home theatre room design
good room
cool room
home theatre design
categories home
theatre room
modern home theatre
futuristic theatre room ideas
basement home theatre
cool theatre room
special theatre room
futuristic theatre room
awesome theatre room

NATURE said...

good article
obat kemaluan keluar nanah
obat untuk kemaluan keluar nanah
obat kemaluan keluar cairan nanah
obat buat kemaluan keluar nanah
pengobatan kemaluan keluar nanah

Anonymous said...

good
Obat Kutil Kelamin
Obat Kondiloma Akuminata
Pengobatan Kondiloma Akuminata
Obat Alami Kondiloma Akuminata Kutil Kelamin
Mengobati Infeksi Kutil di Kemaluan
Mengobati Infeksi Kutil yang Ada di Kelamin
Mengobati Infeksi Kutil Kemaluan
Mengobati Infeksi Kutil Ada di Kemaluan
Mengobati Kutil yang Ada di Kemaluan
Mengobati Kutil di Sekitar Kemaluan
Mengobati Kutil Sekitar Kemaluan
Mengobati Kutil yang Ada di Sekitar Kelamin
Mengobati Virus Kutil yang Ada Kemaluan
Mengobati Virus Kutil Kemaluan
Mengobati Virus Kutil di Kemaluan
Mengobati Virus Kutil yang Ada di Kelamin
Mengobati Kemaluan Wanita Bernanah
Mengobati Kemaluan yang Bernanah
Mengobati Kemaluan Bernanah
Mengobati Kelamin Wanita yang Bernanah
Mengobati Ujung Kemaluan Bernanah
Mengobati Kemaluan yang Bernanah
Mengobati Kemaluan Bernanah
Mengobati Ujung Kelamin yang Bernanah
Mengobati Virus Kemaluan Bernanah
Mengobati Virus di Kemaluan yang Bernanah
Mengobati Kemaluan yang Bernanah
Mengobati Virus Kelamin yang Bernanah
Cara Mengobati Benjolan Ambeien Wasir
Mengobati Benjolan Ambeien
Cara Mengobati Ambeyen
Cara Mengobati Benjolan Ambeien dan Wasir
Cara mengobati sakit wasir
Cara ampuh mengobati wasir
Cara tradisional mengobati wasir
Cara herbal mengobati wasir
Cara Alami Mengobati Wasir Ambeien
Cara Mengobati Wasir
Cara Mengobati Ambeien
Cara Mengobati Wasir Ambeyen
Cara Mengobati Wasir Alami
Cara Mengobati Wasir Herbal
Cara Mengobati Wasir
Cara Alami Mengobati Wasir Ambeien
Mengobati Wasir Tanpa Operasi
Cara Mengobati Wasir Ambeien Tanpa Operasi
Cara Mengobati Wasir Ambeien
Cara Ampuh Mengobati Wasir Tanpa Operasi